What is a defense to a forgery charge?
What is a defense to a forgery charge?
If you are convicted under New York’s Forgery and Criminal Possession of a Forged instrument crimes, you can face serious penalties that have a long-term impact on your future. The complex factual issues involved in white collar criminal offenses like forgery make it important to have the representation of an experienced financial crimes attorneys. Courts often construe aspects of the forgery statute broadly meaning that attorneys who are unfamiliar with these types of charges might have more difficulty mounting an effective defense.
The case of People v. Lydon, 2006 NY Slip Op 7125 (1st Dept. 2006) provides an example of the liberal application of the forgery in the context of crimes involving the unauthorized use of a credit card. The defendant was convicted of multiple counts of forgery although it is unclear whether the defendant was charged with forgery in the third degree under New York Penal Law § 170.05, which is a class A misdemeanor, or forgery in the second degree under New York Penal Law § 170.10, which is a class D felony.
At trial, evidence was introduced that the defendant would contact pizza parlors and order pizzas for delivery. During these telephone calls, the defendant would furnish one of two distinct credit card numbers. Rather than wait for the pizzas to be delivered, the defendant would drive to the pizza parlor and complete the transaction. When it came time to sign the credit card receipts, the defendant would illegibly scrawl gibberish or the name “Mike”. Mike was not the name of either of the credit card holders who were a married couple.
The defendant appealed his forgery conviction based on two separate theories. The first basis for appeal involved the prosecutor’s decision to introduce testimony from only one of the two cardholders. The cardholder that testified indicated that the defendant had not been authorized to use the credit card for the purchase. The defendant contended that because the other cardholder did not appear and testify on the issue of authorization to use the card, the prosecutor had failed to prove that the defendant did not have permission and/or authority to use the credit card.
The appellate court rejected this argument reasoning that the suspicious use of the card, testimony from one of the cardholders and testimony from a representative of the credit card company were sufficient to establish that the defendant did not have permission to use the card from the spouse of the cardholder who testified. The court characterized potential testimony from the spouse who did not appear as a witness as merely cumulative.
The defendant advanced a second basis of appeal that focused on his use of a fictitious name. According to the defense, the use of the fictitious name of “Mike” on the receipts precluded a conviction for forgery. The court rejected this analysis:
“[W]e find that defendant was properly convicted of forgery because his use of a fictitious name was for the purpose of misrepresentation and was accompanied by a ‘fraudulent design”. (Citations omitted). The evidence supports the inference that by scribbling an illegible signature, defendant was not simply signing an assumed name, but was attempting to create the impression that an actual cardholder had signed the documents.” (Citations omitted).
This case demonstrates the importance of retaining an attorney who recognizes the broad construction given by New York judges to state forgery statutes. If you are accused of a white collar felony offense like forgery, you should speak with one of our experienced and aggressive Manhattan criminal defense attorney at Greco Neyland, PC as soon as possible. We provide a free initial consultation, so we can assess your situation and advise you of your rights. Call us today at (212) 951-1300, so we can begin fighting for you.
FREE CONSULTATION
Submit this form to have your case reviewed by our attorney.
Our Practice Areas
Our Offices
Midtown (Main Office)
Greco Neyland, PC
535 5th Ave #2500
New York NY 10017
(212) 951-1300
White Plains
75 S Broadway 4th floor
White Plains, NY 10601
(914) 898-8800
Meet Our Attorneys
Jeffery Greco
Experience as a former prosecutor gives Jeffery Greco and edge in building the strongest possible defense strategy for the accused in Ney York City
Dustan Neyland
A through investigation is key to finding every reasonable doubt and geting charges reduced or dismissed for NYC defense attorney Dustan Neyland.
testimonials
RATED 5/5 BASED ON 52 CUSTOMER REVIEWS
















































share your side
of the story
Give us the details of your case and we will provide a free case evaluation.
share your side
of the story
Give us the details of your case and we will provide a free case evaluation.
CASE RESULTS
FEDERAL FELONY
Client faced a mandatory minimum of 10 years incarceration, we were able to secure a sentence of 1 day in jail.
BURGLARY
Client rejected all plea offers. After the trial concluded, the jury needed only 2 hours to acquit client of all felony charges, and even the criminal mischief charge as well.
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
We were able to convince the Manhattan DA's office to dismiss the case without any ACD at all. The case was dismissed and sealed immediately.
BANK FRAUD
After preparing this case for a JURY TRIAL, the DA's office finally offered a reduced charge and gave my client a no-jail sentence of probation.
CASE RESULTS
FEDERAL FELONY
Client faced a mandatory minimum of 10 years' incarceration, we were able to secure a sentence of 1 day in jail.
BURGLARY
Client rejected all plea offers. After the trial concluded, the jury needed only 2 hours to ACQUIT client of all felony charges, and even the criminal mischief charge as well.
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
We were able to convince the Manhattan DA's office to dismiss the case without any ACD at all. The case was dismissed and sealed immediately.
BANK FRAUD
After preparing this case for a JURY TRIAL, the DA's office finally offered a reduced charge and gave my client a no-jail sentence of probation.
RECENT BLOG POST
The Definitive Guide for Those Charged with Federal Crimes in NYC
When the United States Department of Justice charges you with a crime in New York City, you’ve got a long road ahead. The full weight of the federal government’s law enforcement and prosecutorial machine is arrayed against you. Protecting your freedom and guiding your case to its best possible outcome is going to depend…
Is It a Crime to Insult a Police Officer?
It is not a crime to insult a police officer. It is, in fact, your First Amendment Right to do so. There have even been Supreme Court decisions about this. In 1987, the City of Houston vs. Hill case protected this type of speech, in response to an ordinance that prohibited citizens from “interrupting police…
GRECO NEYLAND, PC 535 5TH AVE #2500, NEW YORK, NY 1017
(212) 951-1300
(CLICK FOR DIRECTIONS)